When Your Loan Goes to the Workout Team
A new banker, new letters, and a different question: not what the business wants next, but whether the bank gets its money back and how. Here is what happens from your side of the table, and what makes the difference.
BY MICHAEL SHANG · SIXTEEN YEARS IN COMMERCIAL BANKING · UPDATED
// THE SHORT ANSWER
When a bank moves a business loan to its workout or business support team, the question changes from what the business wants next to whether the bank gets its money back, and how. Expect a reservation of rights letter, a request for a weekly cash forecast and current accounts, and possibly an independent business review and a standstill with dated milestones. The ways out are a return to the relationship team, a restructure, a refinance elsewhere, a managed sale or a formal process. What helps most is raising the problem first, sending information on time, meeting the milestones and taking your own advice early.
BASIS Practitioner judgment from sixteen years in commercial banking, set out in How Bankers Think (Highbank Press, 2026). Every borrower on this site is a composite constructed for teaching, not a client. The market is mid-market commercial lending as practised in New Zealand and Australia; where a convention differs elsewhere, the page says so.
// MAKE THE CALL
Issue 09 — The Tuesday List. Eight dashboards. Two intensive-care slots. Portfolio triage, Tuesday 8:30am. Your call first, then the senior banker's.
// 01 — WHAT HAS HAPPENED
Your file has moved from the relationship team to a specialist one. Banks call it different things — workout, business support, special assets, credit restructuring, intensive care — and the move usually follows something specific: a covenant breach, a missed payment, a set of accounts that changed the picture, or a pattern the bank had been watching for some time. It is not enforcement. It is a change of question, and Problem Loans and Workout explains why banks make it: the people who made a loan are the least well placed to judge it once it is in trouble, and the skills needed now are different.
The objective has changed too. Your relationship manager's job was to grow a profitable customer; the workout team's job is to recover the bank's money. For a business that is still viable those usually point the same way — a trading business is worth more than its assets sold one by one — which is why most workouts try to keep the business going. But the conversation is no longer about the next facility. It is about the plan, the evidence for it, and whether the people presenting it can be relied on.
// 02 — THE FIRST LETTERS
An information request · a weekly cash forecast, current management accounts, aged debtors and creditors, the tax position
A change to the facility · no further drawings, a reduced limit, default interest while the breach continues
A proposal · an independent review, a standstill, or both
The reservation of rights alarms most borrowers and says less than it seems: it records the default so that carrying on normally cannot later be read as the bank waiving it. The information request says more. A cash forecast week by week, usually for thirteen weeks, is the document the whole workout will run on, because the question has become whether the business can pay its way from here, not whether last year was good. The changes to the facility are the ones your facility letter already allowed — which is the moment to reread it, with an adviser, before replying to anything.
// 03 — THE NEW BANKER
The workout banker is not your relationship manager with a sterner manner. They have seen more businesses in difficulty than you have, they have no stake in the original decision, and they will read your file for three things: whether the business is viable, whether the plan is credible, and whether the information they are getting is complete and on time. The third is the one you control entirely, and it decides more than borrowers expect. A workout banker who is surprised twice stops believing the forecast, and a forecast nobody believes cannot buy time.
So give them one point of contact, on your side, who answers on the day. Send what they ask for when they ask, and say so when you cannot. Tell them bad news before it appears in the numbers — the lost customer, the tax arrears, the supplier who has put you on stop. Your relationship manager may still be in the building and may still be sympathetic, but they are no longer the one deciding, and going around the workout team to them is read as exactly what it is.
// 04 — THE INDEPENDENT BUSINESS REVIEW
The bank may ask an accounting firm to review the business before it decides what to back. The reviewer looks at whether the business is viable, whether the cash forecast holds up, how much the bank's security would realise, and sometimes at management — whether the people running the business are the people to run the recovery. It is the bank's review, of your business, and its conclusions will shape everything after it.
Three things to settle before it starts. Who pays — many facility agreements let the bank recover the cost from the borrower, and in some markets a banking code changes that for smaller businesses; ask, in writing. What the reviewer has been asked to do — the scope decides the report. Whether you will see the conclusions, so you can correct errors of fact before they harden into the bank's view. Then cooperate fully: give access, answer quickly, and treat the reviewer as the person whose report your plan has to survive — because it is. A plan that has already been tested by your own adviser survives better.
// 05 — THE STANDSTILL, FROM YOUR SIDE
A standstill is an agreement by the bank — and by other lenders, if there are any — not to demand repayment or enforce for a set period while the position is worked out. It buys you time on terms, and the terms are worth reading as carefully as the time. Expect to agree to report weekly or monthly, to meet dated milestones — a revised plan, an asset sale, a refinancing offer, new money from the owners — and not to do anything that worsens the lenders' position: no new debt or security, no dividends, no payments to related parties, no disposals outside the ordinary course. There is often a fee.
The default does not go away during a standstill; the bank simply agrees not to act on it for a while. When the period ends, its rights return in full unless something has changed. That makes the milestones the real document: each one met is evidence that the plan and the people are credible, and each one missed makes the next extension harder to get. Agree milestones you can meet rather than ones that sound like the plan you wish you had.
// 06 — THE WAYS OUT
A restructure · repayments rescheduled, part of a line termed out, covenants reset, assets sold, new money from the owners
A refinance out · another lender repays the bank, usually at a higher price
A managed sale · of the business or its assets, by the owners, on their timetable
A formal process · receivership, administration or liquidation, depending on the country and the circumstances
What chooses between them is what each would recover for the bank, set honestly beside the chance it works — the arithmetic the workout guide sets out. A viable business with a credible plan is usually given the chance to run it, because a plan that works recovers more than a sale today. What makes a plan credible is not its ambition but its evidence and the record of the people presenting it. If the plan is a refinance, read Bank Loan vs Private Credit first: the lenders who take these files price for the position, and a dearer loan that does not fix the cash flow only moves the problem.
// 07 — THE GUARANTEE, AND YOUR OWN POSITION
If you signed a personal guarantee, it has just come into view. The workout team will usually ask for a statement of the guarantor's own assets and liabilities early — not because it intends to call the guarantee first, but because it is working out what each way out would recover, and the guarantee is part of that sum. The same goes for the security the bank holds: it will check that it is properly registered and what it would realise.
This is the point to take your own advice, separately from the company's: an accountant, a lawyer, and for a serious position a restructuring adviser. Directors' legal duties sharpen as a company nears insolvency, and the rules differ by country, so the page will not pretend to set them out. What it can say is what every adviser will say first: do not move assets out of the business, do not pay connected parties ahead of other creditors, keep proper records of what was decided and why, and do not sign anything new with the bank until someone on your side has read it.
// 08 — WHAT HELPS, AND WHAT HURTS
What helps: raising the problem before the bank does, which is what the businesses that come through a workout most often have in common; your own weekly cash forecast, sent before it is asked for; a plan that names what has already been done, not only what will be; owners putting something in, even a little, because it shows who carries the risk; milestones met; and bad news told early. What hurts: silence; forecasts that miss by the same margin every month; going around the workout banker; payments to connected parties; optimism presented as a plan; and treating the standstill as a holiday rather than the deadline it is. The bank is reading the same things it reads on a monthly pack in good times — punctuality, candour, forecast against actual — with far more depending on them.
Most businesses that come through a workout are the ones whose owners treated it as a negotiation about evidence rather than a fight or a confession. The bank wants its money back, and in most cases the cheapest way to get it is for your business to survive. Help it see how.
// QUESTIONS BORROWERS ASK
- What is a reservation of rights letter from a bank?
- A letter in which the bank says it knows about a default, is not acting on it now, and is not giving up its right to act later. Banks send it because carrying on as normal after a known default can be argued to have waived it. It is usually the first formal letter a business receives as its file moves toward the specialist team, and it is not a demand for repayment. Read it with your adviser, answer what it asks for, and take it as the sign that the relationship has changed lanes.
- Who pays for an independent business review?
- It depends on the facility agreement and, in some markets, on the banking code the bank has signed. Many agreements let the bank recover its costs, including an accountant it instructs, from the borrower; some codes of practice change that for smaller businesses. Ask before the review starts who is paying, what the accountant has been asked to do, and whether you will see the conclusions. The answer should be in writing.
- Can I refinance while my loan is with the workout team?
- Yes, and often the workout team would welcome it — a refinance that repays the bank in full is one of its best outcomes. Expect the new lender to ask why you are leaving and to read the same numbers the workout team is reading, so the price will reflect the position, and specialist lenders who do this work charge more than a bank. Tell the workout team you are looking. A credible refinancing in progress is a reason for the bank to allow time; a secret one discovered late is not.
- Will the bank call my personal guarantee?
- Not usually first, and rarely while the business has a credible plan. A guarantee becomes relevant when the bank is working out how much it would recover in each of the ways out, and the workout team will ask for a statement of the guarantor's own position early for that reason. Whether and when it is called depends on the guarantee's terms and on how the business's own position resolves. Take independent advice on your guarantee as soon as the file moves, not when a demand arrives.
- How long does a loan stay with the workout team?
- As long as it takes to reach one of the ways out, which can be a few months or more than a year. A business whose plan works and whose numbers recover can be handed back to the relationship team; one that refinances elsewhere leaves; one that is sold or enters a formal process ends there. The standstill, if there is one, sets the first milestones, and meeting them is what keeps the timetable yours rather than the bank's.
// THE OTHER SIDE OF THE TABLE
Issue 09 is a portfolio review: eight borrowers, two intensive-care places, and a bank deciding whose file moves. See what the desk reads before it moves one, and how much of the reason was the calendar.
Work Issue 09 →