Two clients want the last of a limited fixed-rate funding scheme the bank is offering. One is your largest relationship; the other applied first and qualifies equally.

Ground floor · The hall
Personal Banker
The bank's face in a branch or on a phone: everyday accounts, cards, personal lending and the first conversation about a home loan.
BY MICHAEL SHANG · SIXTEEN YEARS IN COMMERCIAL BANKING · UPDATED
// 01 — WHAT A PERSONAL BANKER DOES
Most of the day is other people's ordinary money — an account opened, a limit raised, a payment that did not arrive, a customer who cannot make this month's repayment. The lending is small, standardised and decided against a policy grid rather than a written argument, which makes it a volume seat rather than a judgment one.
// 02 — WHO ARRIVES HERE
The most open door in the bank: school leavers, graduates, career changers and people out of retail and hospitality all arrive here, and more senior bankers came through it than through any other seat.
// 03 — WHAT THE INTERVIEW ASKS
These are the shapes the round takes, not a question bank — banks phrase them differently and the wording is never the point.
- 01Tell me about a time you turned an unhappy customer around.
- 02A customer wants something the policy will not give them. What do you say?
- 03How would you notice someone is in financial difficulty before they tell you?
- 04You are behind on your targets with a week left. What do you do?
- 05A colleague is doing something you think breaches policy. What then?
- 06Why a bank, and why this one?
What the panel is listening for. Whether you can hold a commercial target and a duty to the customer in the same conversation without dropping either — the whole conduct question in miniature.
Practise the round in the front-line quiz: one of its five questions is this seat's own, and every answer has the senior interviewer's read.
Take the quiz →// 04 — WHY CREDIT PAYS IN THIS SEAT
What you learn here about how people actually behave under repayment pressure is the same instinct a business lender applies to a larger balance sheet; the counter is where most credit careers get their first thousand repetitions.
Most people in this seat are asked, sooner or later, whether they want to move across to business lending. The move is shorter than it looks: a small business's accounts are a household's finances with more lines, and the question — will the money come back, and what if it does not — is the one the counter asks every day.
START HERE · Credit analysis for beginners
// 05 — A DAY IN THE SEAT
- 08:45The queue before the doors open: yesterday's follow-ups, a card that did not arrive, a limit that needs a second look.
- 10:00A first conversation about a home loan — what the customer earns, owes and expects, before any number is typed in.
- 11:30A customer who cannot make this month's repayment, and the hardship conversation the policy expects you to have properly.
- 13:00A personal lending request decided against the grid — and the one that sits on the line, where you have to say why.
- 14:30A complaint that is really about a fee, and a referral: a customer whose personal account has started to look like a business.
- 16:00The day's numbers against the target, and the difference between the sales that were right for the customer and the ones that were not.
The shape of a day, not a rota — banks and books differ. A relationship manager's day is on what a commercial banker does.
// 06 — WHAT THE FIRST YEAR TESTS
- Whether you can hold a target and a duty to the customer in the same conversation, week after week.
- Whether you notice difficulty before the customer names it — the changed pattern, the late payment, the question asked twice.
- Whether your accuracy holds at volume: the account opened correctly, the identity checked, the note written.
- Whether you know what the policy grid is protecting, so the customer on the line gets an explanation rather than a shrug.
- Whether the business banking team trusts your referrals — the first test of whether you can read a business at all.
// 07 — WHAT YOU SEE FROM HERE
The retail machine from the inside: a scorecard deciding thousands of small loans, and the customers who do not fit it — the ones a person has to read. The counter also sees, before anyone else, which household has become a business and which business is quietly failing, because the account behaviour arrives here first.
// 08 — THE FILES TO PRACTISE ON
- ISSUE 06Kowhai Retail GroupA retailer at Christmas — a business your customers shop at, read from the other side of the counter.
- ISSUE 04Highview IndustriesWhat a business file looks like when the answer is yes: the crossing into business lending, in one file.
- ISSUE 01Pacific Premium FoodsThe same request, declined — and why a bigger limit is not always the kind thing to give.
// 09 — WHERE THE SEAT LEADS
Business banking is the usual next seat, and this site's own subject. Others lead a branch, move into operations, product or fraud, or across to the specialist teams behind the contact centre. Many senior bankers started at a counter, which is the honest reason to take it.
// 10 — READ BEFORE THE ROUND
- Commercial banking vs retail banking
What changes when a person reads the file instead of a scorecard.
- Credit analysis for beginners
The first read of a set of accounts, for the day a business customer asks.
- Commercial banking interview questions
The panel's shape for credit and relationship seats, including the client who wants something that is not right for them.
THE IN-TRAY · ONE MINUTE
Make the call on one file.
A short file on the ground this page covers. Every option opens with how far it sits from a senior banker’s read.
1 FILES · PICK A CALL ON ANY OF THEM
4 MORE ON THE CONDUCT · FAIR DEALING →WHERE DO YOU READ FROM? THE PLACEMENT →
// ALSO IN THE FRONT LINE
- Business relationship manager
- Corporate coverage banker
- Agribusiness manager
- Private banker
- Markets salesperson
- Trader
- Transaction banker
- Product manager
The whole board, and how the four blocks fit together, is on what jobs banks hire for.
// SUBSCRIBE
The Lab.
One case file and one question, in your inbox every Tuesday morning, New Zealand time. The senior banker's read opens only after you answer.
FREE WITH IT · 10-PAGE PDF
Case 01 of the interview case pack — Northmark Engineering, in full.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Educational content only.
